In this article you’ll discover…
- 3 reasons receiving a compliment can feel so hard – and a powerful reframe
- 5 rules to respond to any man with confidence + spark a new connection
- How to turn a compliment into a meaningful moment (without overthinking)
Introduction
Receiving a genuine compliment from someone can feel surprisingly hard.
And if it’s coming from a guy you’re attracted to, welcome to Flusterville.
If that feels familiar, know that you’re not alone in wondering how to respond to a compliment from a guy.
And I’m willing to bet that hearing the tired (and unhelpful) advice to “just say thank you” is really irritating.
That’s because that’s the “what” but not the “how.”
Especially if you’re trying to build real-world confidence and create authentic, offline connections like I teach in my book The Offline Dating Method.

So, what’s a compliment-getting gal to do?
In this article, I’ll help get you from awkward to authentic with simple, powerful scripts to spark a connection from the very first compliment – or anything else a man says when he approaches you!
Why Just Say ‘Thanks’ Doesn’t Cut It
First, let’s dive deeper into the annoying “Just say thank you” advice out there.
Because here’s the problem: saying “thank you” without engagement ends the moment before it even has a chance to get going. It’s a polite sentence, but it doesn’t move the conversation forward at all.
So, a well-intentioned compliment (or question, or comment) has now become an awkward moment – and that experience gets burned into your psyche as associating compliments with awkwardness.
To that I say, “Boo”
If a guy is trying to connect with you, you likely have an aspect he’s drawn to and his compliment is likely his brave attempt to approach you and start a conversation.
A kind but rather flat “Thanks” in response can signal that you’re disinterested, even if that’s not true – and you, of course, think of the most perfect thing to say 23 minutes after it happens (but he’s long gone).
If compliments sometimes make you squirm, it’s super normal.
Most women default to short, polite responses out of habit – not because doing so feels good.
That’s simply what society has taught us: to downplay individual praise and don’t think you’re better than anyone else.
We’ve learned:
- Not to appear “too full of ourselves”
- Being noticed might be unsafe or unwanted
- We must instantly return the compliment to avoid looking self-centered
- We’re now responsible to “even out the compliment balance” by immediately giving one back
None of those aspects are your truth – they’re your social programming.
What if, instead, receiving a compliment became an enjoyable confidence builder instead of a moment of tension – and you felt more confident talking to guys in general?
As much as you can, reframe a compliment you get (or question or comment) as a gift and try to receive it with grace just like you would a physical present that, say, your mom just gave you for your birthday.
Receiving energy is feminine energy and – just like social skill muscles – it can be taught through awareness and practice.
It takes strength and softness to hold someone’s praise without needing to “earn” it. That’s where real connection begins: when you simply let kind words in and trust that you’re worthy of them.
When you think ahead about how to respond to a compliment, before the next one inevitably happens, you’ve prepared to create an opening that might just change the course of your life – especially your love life.
The 5 Rules of Engagement When He Approaches
Now, let’s cover what to do when a man tries to start a conversation with you – including simple scripts to respond to him in a way that feels comfortable.
Rule #1: Assume He’s Interested
“Shall we all look for some ribbon together?”
Mr. Wickham to the Bennet sisters, Pride and Prejudice (2005)
If a man approaches you, assume he has an interest in you until proven otherwise; i.e. assume that you are a woman he finds attractive on some level.
Chances are, he’s not interested in the weather he just commented on, or looking for some ribbon, or whatever other random topic he used as a reason to engage you.
He’s interested in talking to you, my dear.
Here’s an example: one of my workshop students, Maddy, had a pink crystal necklace that she wore almost every day.
When I shared my approachability tip to “dress for confidence and a conversation,” here’s what she said…
- Maddy: “Oh, I wear my pink crystal necklace everywhere and men always come up and comment on it.”
- Me: “Perfect! How do you respond to keep the conversation going?”
- Maddy: “I say thanks and walk away…Oh. Shoot.”
We sent some gratitude to all the men who had approached Maddy using her pink crystal necklace as an excuse to engage her, but had been unintentionally shot down because she was clueless.
Rule #2: Find the Positive
While there are general patterns across human behavior, layered on top of those are every person’s unique personality, emotions, sense of humor, and other aspects that fluctuate day to day, even moment to moment.
If you find yourself not completely understanding what someone said to you or questioning the intention behind what they said, don’t immediately jump to a negative conclusion.
Always assume they meant it in the best possible way and then ask a question to clarify, like…
- “What do you mean?”
- “Why is that?”
- “Tell me more about that.”
This “perceive as positive” approach will not only stop you from being offended by well-meaning (albeit slightly inarticulate) people, but questions like the examples above give the conversation a chance to go deeper, as opposed to continuing the discussion while you secretly remain offended.
Defaulting to a positive assumption will change your general outlook on life in a great way.
For instance, one afternoon my friend and I were on a luxury home tour and wandered into a room separate from the main area. Suddenly a woman came up to us and said…
“Excuse me, only models and caterers are supposed to be in here. Are you two models?”
We could have been offended or embarrassed, but since my default is to assume the positive, my first thought was, “She asked if I was a model! Who cares if she was just being polite, that’s awesome!” So, I said…
“Nope, but thanks for thinking we might be!”
It turned a potentially awkward situation into a fun and flattering experience. I mean, who doesn’t want to be mistaken for a model?
Another example is from the movie Dumb and Dumber. The main character, Harry, is attending a charity auction and walks up to a beautiful woman and says…
“Nice set of hooters you got there.”
The woman turns to him with disdain and says…
“I beg your pardon?”
Then the camera zooms out and shows that they’re standing in front of a pair of owls, the subject of the charity auction. Harry quickly clarifies…
“The owls, they’re beautiful.”
Lesson learned: Ask clarifying questions before jumping to offense.

Rule #3: Accept All Compliments
If you’re wondering what to say when a guy says you’re pretty, we’ll cover some powerful scripts here in Rule #3.
Accepting compliments can be challenging for many people because we’ve been taught to not “stray from the pack” and risk being seen as different from others.
One of my favorite exercises from my live workshops is when I ask each attendee to turn to the woman sitting next to her and give her a genuine compliment.
The rule is that the woman receiving the compliment is not allowed to give one in return nor deflect it. She can only say “Thank you” and describe the complimented object and/or what the compliment meant to her (e.g. “Thank you, what a sweet thing to say!”).
Since many women’s knee-jerk reaction to receiving a compliment is to immediately scramble to return one back, the first round of this exercise is always a little awkward.
But after running through a few rounds, “Thank you” started to become the new comfortable default response as the ladies pushed past their fear of coming off as ungrateful and settled into simply receiving the kind words as a gift.
An example of this self-deprecating phenomenon taken to a hilarious extreme is the skit “Compliments” from the show Inside Amy Schumer.
The scene is a series of female friends dishing out heartfelt compliments to each other… only to have each woman take the compliment she was given and turn it into an insult about herself. Here’s one of the scripts:
- Woman 1: “Oh my God Brie, you dyed your hair it looks amazing!”
- Woman 2: “Oh no you’re just being nice.”
- Woman 1: “No seriously it looks great.”
- Woman 2: “No, I tried to look like Kate Hudson but ended up looking like a Golden Retriever’s dingleberry.”
If your own natural reaction to a compliment is to immediately give one back or downplay it, pause and think about how that feels when you do it.
Probably not very good; or, as one of my clients, Emma, put it, “It feels like I’m just throwing away their compliment.”
Well said, Emma.
A good reframe is to visualize someone’s compliment as them handing a physical gift to you. Would your first reaction be to immediately give it back to them, or take them to the place they bought it and return it right in front of them?
Of course not.
You’d simply say, “Thank you!” and accept it. So do the exact same thing with every compliment you receive.
As with gift-giving, the person paying the compliment almost always feels more joy from giving it than the person receiving it. So, if you struggle to receive kind words, start by accepting them for the sake of making the other person feel good.
Compliments can also serve as great icebreakers.
The next time you receive a compliment, instead of saying, “Thanks!” which can feel awkward because it just hangs there, try describing the action or the topic you were just gifted.
For example, if someone holds the door open for you, you could say…
- “Thanks for holding the door open for me.”
- “Well aren’t you a gentleman. Thank you.”
Or tell a little story about whatever you were just complimented on. Maybe someone said they liked your bracelet. Tell a short backstory on why or where you got it, and end with a question back to them to keep the conversation going. For instance:
- “Thank you, I love vintage jewelry. What caught your eye about it?”
- “Are you into vintage jewelry too?”
- “Red’s my favorite color – sounds like you’re a fan too?”
This hits the metaphorical conversation ball back to the other person and gives the interaction a direction to go in, without scrambling to find an immediate compliment to come back with.
If you struggle with accepting compliments, know that’s totally normal. There’s often an internal shame‑vs‑agree tension that occurs where you want to receive the compliment but are feeling guilty for taking without immediately giving back.
To overcome this, choose a go-to compliment acceptance approach now, before you get a compliment, so you have a plan ready to go:
- Describe the action or topic he complimented you on.
- Or tell a little story about it (guides convo better).
- Have a question to ask back after accepting a compliment.
These approaches also help with how to respond to a flirty compliment then organically build it into a deeper connection.
Rule #4: Just Go With It
Unless you’re feeling a “something is seriously off with this guy” vibe, go with the flow of whatever he said so you can help him kick off the conversation.
Imagine the situation from his perspective: he spots you, a woman he’s attracted to, and wants to get your attention before he misses his chance.
He’s trying to think on his feet, so it’s probably going to be a random topic.
Another exercise I led my workshop attendees through illustrates how hard it is for a man to come up with something to say to a woman on the spot.
I paired up attendees, with one woman playing herself and the other woman wearing a male celebrity mask (David Beckham, Brad Pitt, Johnny Depp, Prince William, or Will.I.Am) to play the part of the man she encounters.

I then give each pair a scene – such as, “Heidi is on the bus going to work, reading a book about a remote Amazonian tribe… when suddenly Prince William’s twin sits down next to her – what can he say to get her attention?”
Not only does this allow the women to get comfortable thinking on their feet, but it also gives them a whole new appreciation for how nerve-wracking it can feel to approach someone and try to engage them without being too weird or creepy.
Because one sign of good man is that he’s conscious about your comfort and doesn’t want to creep you out.
It’s also impossible to take yourself seriously when wearing these masks, which are about 30% larger than a normal face.
So remember, whatever a man says to engage you, as long as it isn’t totally offensive, try to just go with it and help him out. He’ll appreciate it, and you can both benefit from getting the conversation party started.
Embrace the “Yes, and…”
A good mantra to keep in mind when talking to people you meet for the first time is the “Yes, and…” rule of improv comedy.
That means whatever the other person says, you find some way to agree and/or build upon it to keep the conversation moving in a positive direction.
It’s the same technique they use in the TV show, Whose Line Is It Anyway? where comedians are given a scene, then work together in the moment to play it out.
You’ll never hear anyone shut down the skit by disagreeing with whatever random thing comes out of the other comedian’s mouth. They always use the “Yes, and…” approach.

A real-life example of this was when I was in a drug store searching for the perfect card for my friend’s birthday, when a man came up to me and said…
“Any good ones in there?”
Since my default response to strangers is the same as it is to my friends – and tends to involve humor – I said…
“Well, there are definitely some strange ones.”
I then showed him the awkward card I was holding, we shared a laugh, and he ended up asking for my phone number.
Another example was at a charity event; I was standing by myself waiting for a friend to arrive when a woman I didn’t know came up to me and said…
“Are you Christine’s friend?”
I could have just said “No” and ended it there. But instead, I saw the opportunity to make a connection and said…
“Nope. But hi, I’m Camille. So, who’s Christine?”
The woman and I ended up hanging out the rest of the night and having a great time together.
I’ve also had men approach me with some seemingly random lines – many of which led to being asked out by them, because I knew exactly what was happening and just rolled with it…
Example 1
- Man #1: “Do you know where the nearest pizza place is?”
- Me: “Not off the top of my head, but what kind of are you looking for?”
Example 2
- Man #2: “Did you catch the Blackhawks game last night?”
- Me: “I missed it, how’d they do?”
So be on the lookout for those random comments and questions.
Go beyond their face value and look at the possible intention behind them – then see where it goes!
FEATURED PRODUCT
Want a Hot Date This Weekend?

I’ll show you how to walk into a coffee shop, grocery store, anywhere IRL…
…and capture the attention of any man you want to – even if you’re shy.
(plus get the 1 simple phrase that inspires him to ask you out)
Grab my digital course 3 Steps to Your First Date IRL…
Rule #5: Don’t Be Cruel
Never put a man (or anyone) down – even if you’re “just joking.”
I used to do this to men I liked because I was scared they could see I was interested in them. So I’d go to the extreme opposite in how I treated them.
Not only did it feel awful, but it definitely didn’t get me any dates – at least not with the right men.
Usually we “bring out the mean” when we’re afraid of being rejected. It’s easier to tell yourself that if you reject someone else first, then it doesn’t matter if they reject you. But that approach only means you’re rejecting everyone, all the time, and never truly connecting with anyone.
If you’re feeling nervous, check out my blog How to Overcome the Four Social Fears to become a pro at initiating a conversation – even if that feels terrifying for you right now.
Sometimes people can be short or defensive as a default reaction to someone who simply caught them off guard.
I always recommend doing a quick scan of every place you step into, so you can spot men before they approach you, and thus feel safer when they do.
If your sense of humor is more on the sarcastic side, lead with the kindest part of that until you and the person you just met get to know each other a little more, so they can tell when you’re joking versus being serious.
Also, try to find something to continue the conversation that feels genuinely interesting to you. I’m not a sports fan, so I’ll never start an interaction off on a lie pretending to be interested in sports.
But whenever that topic comes up in random conversations (especially when I know it’s simply being used to engage me), I’ll find something positive in it while still being honest, such as…
- “I don’t follow sports closely, but I always enjoy a live game.”
- “I’m not big on sports, but I like movies about sports.”
When a Compliment Crosses the Line
Sometimes a comment or compliment doesn’t feel good, and a boundary needs to be set. Here’s how to handle those situations…
Trust Your Gut
Not every compliment deserves your time or respect.
If a guy makes a comment that feels inappropriate, negative, or entitled, it’s time to end the conversation.

Here are some red flags to watch for:
- His tone feels aggressive or unsafe
- Your body tenses up or wants to retreat
- He makes the compliment sexual without your consent
Listen to your feminine intuition. You don’t need a logical reason to walk away, just do it.
Set a Respectful Boundary
You get to decide who gets access to you and your energy, compliments included.
If someone’s approach did not sit well with you, here are a few ways to set a boundary with them:
- “That was a little too forward for me.”
- “No, thank you. I’m good.”
- “That was unkind / disrespectful of you. I’m no longer interested in continuing this conversation.”
Conclusion: How to Respond to a Compliment From a Guy
Let’s recap the key takeaways:
- Feeling awkward when complimented is normal – you’re unlearning years of playing small
- “Just say thanks” to a compliment doesn’t further connection; add a next step to keep it going.
- Connection starts with reception, when you allow a compliment to land
- You can set boundaries with grace in one simple statement
Whether you’re in a grocery store, at a party, or just walking down the sidewalk, knowing how to respond to a compliment from a man (especially IRL) is an opportunity to create a powerful, potentially lifelong, connection.
So next time it happens, take a breath.
Hold his gaze.
Respond with something that feels true to you – with as much or as little as you like.
You’ve got this.




