In this article you’ll discover…
- What causes dating anxiety and how to shift those thoughts
- The 4 social fears that are blocking attraction IRL
- Simple strategies to stop being so nervous around men
Introduction
“Why do I get so nervous around him?!” my client Claire said to me the other day.
If you’ve ever been struck with an instant “Ahhhhh…. Ummmmm…” inability to form a full sentence around a guy you’re attracted to, you’re not alone.
That rush of blush to the face, the frozen mouth, the scramble for something to say, it’s all both common and normal.
Attraction and dating can feel overwhelming, especially when your emotions are tied up in every little smile, glance, or awkward silence.
But the truth is, nervousness around someone you’re attracted to isn’t just “in your head” – it’s wired into your biology and shaped by past experiences.
From fear of rejection to social conditioning, these feelings are rooted in very real, very human psychology.
And you can absolutely overcome them.
In this article, we’ll explore what’s really behind those nerves. You’ll uncover how rejection sensitivity, dating anxiety, and your own inner voice might be holding you back – and more importantly, how to gently break through those barriers.
With a few mindset shifts and a few simple tools, you’ll feel more grounded, confident, and ready to connect… even with your biggest crush.
Why You Get Nervous Around Him
Here’s what’s actually happening when you feel “nervous”…
Ancient Fears in Modern Dating
Your nervousness around someone you’re attracted to (i.e. the potential rejection by them) isn’t a flaw, it’s an intentional survival response.
Thousands of years ago, being accepted by your tribe was essential. Rejection from a community to fend for yourself literally meant certain death.
Even today, your (wired-in-ancient-times) brain still perceives rejection as a serious threat. This biological phenomenon makes the idea of starting a conversation with a crush feel terrifying – even though the actual risk is small.
So if you’ve ever thought, “Why do I get nervous around him?”… it’s because your brain is trying to protect you. It’s just using an outdated system.
Rejection Sensitivity and ADHD Links
If you’ve ever felt crushed by the tiniest bit of criticism or ghosting, you might be dealing with rejection sensitivity. This is especially common in people with ADHD, Highly Sensitive People (HSPs), or those who’ve experienced emotional trauma.
Rejection Sensitivity Dysphoria (RSD) is a term used to describe an extreme emotional response to perceived rejection. It can turn a small social stumble into a spiral of shame and anxiety.
Here are some common aspects of RSD:
- Intense emotional reactions to perceived rejection or criticism (even mild or imagined)
- Deep feelings of shame, embarrassment, or worthlessness after rejection
- Sudden mood shifts (going from fine to devastated) triggered by interpersonal conflict or disapproval
- People-pleasing or avoidance behaviors to prevent potential rejection
- Ruminating or overanalyzing interactions for signs of disapproval
- Impulsive withdrawal or shutting down after criticism or conflict
But the good news?
Awareness is the first step to healing.
If you feel any of those aspects, know that you’re not broken – you’re beautifully wired to feel deeply.
Now it’s time to channel that sensitivity into strength and confidence.
The Four Social Fears
F.E.A.R. = False Evidence Appearing Real
It’s completely normal to feel some anxiety about the prospect of talking to men – especially if you’re a little out of practice.
Through my own personal experiences, as well as my clients’, I’ve found four common fears that tend crop up during the initial connection process.
Let’s dive into the four most common engagement fears and techniques to quickly overcome them, so you feel empowered to push past them and start initiating great conversations with quality men (who are looking for the same in a woman).

#1 Fear of Rejection
“It is only ONE person’s opinion. There are 7 billion+ people in the world and everyone has opinions, usually hundreds per day. Their opinion of you is largely an instinctual response to being presented with new stimulus – which means it is more about them, than it is you.”
Jesse Krieger
The best way to overcome this fear is by using my “Friendly or Flirting?” technique, which is when you simply talk to someone the same way you would a friend and become the friendly person who talks to everybody.
When you say something casual and specific to a man, like “Cool leather bag, where’d you get it?” he has no clue if you’re using that as an icebreaker because you’re interested in him, or if you just want to know where he got his bag.
This also lowers the fear of rejection for both you and him – and when you lower the fear of rejection, you raise your level of engagement and the chance that you’ll naturally get the outcome that you want (like, say, having him ask you out).
Maybe you’re standing in the cereal aisle of the grocery store and spot a cute guy a few feet away who’s checking out a box of granola.
Ask yourself, “If he was a woman, and I actually had a question about that granola he’s looking at, what would I say?” – and then simply say that to him.

Just ask yourself: “What would I say to a woman?” and then say the same thing to him. Done and done.
It’s a natural question that’s instantly relatable and has a purpose. No need to come up with the “perfect line” that would probably be out of context and come across as trying too hard (which will feel awkward anyway).
Just ask a normal question and see where it goes. Zero pressure and way more fun.
A client of mine, Zelda, had this happen to her unexpectedly one time at Trader Joe’s. She and her friend were both in the bread aisle, about 15 feet apart from each other.
When Zelda found the bread she was looking for, she said to her friend, “Hey, Anna! Found the bread, you’re gonna love it – it’s really buttery.”
That’s when a man who was standing between them, apparently a fan of buttery bread, chimed in by asking, “Sounds good. Which bread?” – and they started chatting!
He could have been trying to flirt with her, or he could have just really wanted to get a good bread recommendation.
Who knows, who cares.
They ended up connecting, which was all that mattered.
#2 Fear of Being Awkward
If you have a fear of saying something awkward, chances are you’ve over-compensated for that by trying to craft the “perfect” line then force it to come off natural and “in the moment.” This will definitely contribute to your feelings of nervousness around men.
The unfortunate irony with this approach is that by taking the time to craft a “more natural” sentence you completely strip it of being natural, which will make it feel and sound even more awkward.
The longer you hesitate to say something, the bigger your fear of saying it will grow.
The quickest way to overcome this fear is to use my “Mind to Mouth Move.”
To apply it, catch the first thought that pops in your head about the person you want to engage, then say it out loud to them before you give yourself the chance to overthink it. In other words, take your first thought immediately from your mind to your mouth.
This prevents you from over-rehearsing what to say and ultimately psyching yourself out from saying it.
Over time, practicing this technique will build trust in yourself that whatever you end up saying, it will do the job just fine.

So maybe you have a thought like, “Wow, that woman’s pashmina would go great with my dress for my cousin’s bar mitzvah. I wonder where she got it.”
Immediately go over to her and say, “Excuse me, I love your pashmina. Where’d you get it?”
Do not hesitate.
Do not try to reword.
Do not talk yourself out of it.
And always keep whatever you share positive.
When you make it a habit to say it as soon as it pops in your head, your fear doesn’t have the chance to creep in. The more you practice this, the faster you’ll get and the of a natural habit it will become.
Plus, you’ll continually prove to yourself that, overall, people are very receptive to talking to you – and it’s fun!
#3 Fear of Being Creepy
While this may feel like a valid fear, let me point out that it’s more difficult for a woman to come across as creepy.
Not impossible, but difficult. For better or for worse, the word “creep” is socially coded to men. Sorry guys.
For example, if a woman brushes up against a man’s leg in the middle of a conversation, chances are he’s not going to feel disrespected or violated. If a man does that to a woman, he will likely be labeled a creep.
Yes, it’s a double standard, but it is what it is.
Being creepy usually boils down to not respecting someone’s personal space or lingering too long past the point when an interaction would have naturally come to a close.
So, as long as you’re not running your hands all over every person you meet and are paying attention to basic social cues, take heart that, as a female, you are more than likely far from coming across as a creep.
#4 Fear He’s Already Taken
Another reason why you get nervous around men might be that you’re worried he’s already in a relationship and you don’t want to be disrespectful of that.
True, you don’t want to overstep your bounds if a man you find attractive is off the market.
The problem with stopping yourself from engaging like this is: other than wearing a wedding ring or having a woman on his arm, it’s impossible to know if a man is “taken” or not by simply looking at him.
The best way to find out if a man is single is to engage him and see where he takes the connection.
By being your authentic self with everyone, you’re simply starting conversations with fellow humans about everyday topics. It’s not disrespectful to acknowledge a man or ask him a question, no matter what his relationship status is.
I would even argue that it’s prejudiced to purposefully avoid talking to a man simply because he has a wedding ring on. Married men need human connection too!
Use my easy icebreakers to engage him in a casual question, comment, or compliment. Then wait for a signal that he’s interested in continuing the conversation. Because it is his responsibility to let you know at some point that he’s taken. You’re not a mind reader.
When you choose not to engage with a man because you’re afraid he’s already taken, you are making the decision for him that he wouldn’t enjoy a conversation with you.
That’s not fair to him, and I don’t want you hindering your own pursuit of a great partner for the sake of that tiny risk.
That’s like chatting up someone at a party, offering to grab them a glass of wine, and having them respond that they don’t drink alcohol.
Ok, no big deal. You were just being nice and had no way of knowing they didn’t drink.
Would a moment like that prevent you from ever offering to grab a drink for another person again?
Of course not, you had only good intentions and didn’t have the context to know this person’s personal preference.
So, if you get your confidence up, talk to a guy, and then he suddenly brings up a girlfriend or wife in the middle of your conversation, there’s no need to get embarrassed.
Again, how were you supposed to know she was in the picture if she wasn’t physically there?
Instead, do this: purposefully incorporate her into the conversation.
Ask what her name is, and/or my personal favorite question about how they met each other. I love those stories!
Taking this approach to acknowledge his significant other will not only feel more respectful and less awkward in the moment, but it’ll also empower you to chat up any man – because if he happens to reveal his relationship mid-conversation you now know exactly how to handle it with grace and ease.
FEATURED PRODUCT
Want a Hot Date This Weekend?

I’ll show you how to walk into a coffee shop, grocery store, anywhere IRL…
…and capture the attention of any man you want to – even if you’re shy.
(plus get the 1 simple phrase that inspires him to ask you out)
Grab my digital course 3 Steps to Your First Date IRL…
How to Stop Being Nervous Around Him
Going beyond the scripts and tips provided for each fear, here are a few techniques to conquer your social anxieties at a deeper level…
Practice Emotional Rewiring
One of the best ways to move past each of the four fears is to disprove it.
This can be done by actively looking for and building a body of evidence that supports the opposite of what you’re afraid of.
When your fear goes unquestioned or unproven for too long, it can grow to massive proportions and lodge in your head as a “fact.”
For example, an initial thought like, “I can’t talk to people I don’t know because they might think I’m weird,” put on repeat in your head every day for years can easily turn into, “When I talk to strangers they think I’m a weirdo,” and subconsciously accepting it as truth.
To move past this, first start to question those anxieties by asking yourself, “What am I truly afraid of when talking to people?”
The more you understand where your fear is coming from, the more you start to challenge it.
Next, ask yourself what’s the worst that might actually happen if you played out the scenario you’re afraid of.
I guarantee it’s not going to be that bad.
Simply naming the fear and then thinking of the most terrifying outcome possible (which won’t actually be possible) gives the fear less power and enables you to start dispelling it.
The goal here is to prove your fear wrong by creating new experiential memories that support the outcome you desire – i.e. the opposite of what you’ve been afraid would happen.
Overcome your negative fear by creating an experience that proves the positive opposite of it.
By creating a new experience, you’re replacing formerly negative emotions with new positive experiences.
Humans change their behavior on an emotional level, not a logical level. That’s why experiencing a situation that disproves your fear is 100 times more effective in dispelling it than trying to logically reason it away.
After years of proving wrong my own debilitating fears with engaging people, I’ve now spoken with thousands of strangers and the worst thing that’s ever happened was that a few people didn’t acknowledge me.
And hey, I’m still alive!
Practice Emotional Rewiring
The next time your mind starts spinning with “what ifs,” try this: name your fear.
Literally say, “I’m afraid he’ll…..think I’m awkward.” Or, “I’m afraid he’ll…tell me he’s out of my league or I’m not worthy of even talking to him.”
Now those are some honest answers – and ones you can finally start to question and tease apart to undo the knot of anxiety they’ve been causing.
Next, ask: “If I do talk to him, what else might happen instead? What’s one good thing that might happen?”
This is called cognitive reframing and it’s very powerful. It helps you see the situation through a more balanced lens and question what isn’t serving you.
Visualize a positive outcome: He smiles. You both laugh. Maybe he’s nervous too, and instantly feels more at ease because he felt that sentiment from you first.
By practicing this new narrative, you begin creating emotional safety with connection and dating, including within yourself.
Build Confidence Through Action
Confidence doesn’t come from thinking – it comes from doing.
The smallest action, like asking someone for the time or giving a compliment, actually rewires your brain.
The more experiences you have where your fear doesn’t come true, the more you trust yourself and prove to your inner critic that you’re ready to let that negative thought go now.

So start small. Pick one person each day to say hello to. Let that be enough for now.
Before long, you’ll be striking up flirty conversations in the frozen foods aisle without thinking twice, wondering how you ever went through the day without the ability to casually chat up people on demand.
Conclusion: Why Do I Get Nervous Around Him?
Let’s recap the fear-conquering transformation you’re working toward:
- Nervousness is normal—and even rooted in ancient survival
- Rejection sensitivity can be rewired with awareness and self-compassion
- Fear loses power when you take intentional action to experience its opposite
- Emotional safety comes from proving your fear wrong in real life
Remember: You’re not here to impress. You’re here to connect and show someone a little glimpse of the awesomeness that is you.
So the next time your nerves kick in, breathe deep. Smile. Speak. You’ve got this.
And if you need a little more help and support, here are options for us to work together.




